Captain Sy “Cyclops” Petcher had always been known to exaggerate. He told fancy yarns to anyone at the Triple Trout who would buy him ale for a tale. He wore an eye patch over his right eye ever since a hurricane that he claims gave his the ability to see the future. After his passing, his grandchildren Oliver and Sophia are tasked with selling his seaside home. Oliver is ready to wipe his hands clean of the old scallywag, but Sophia wistfully remembers better times. When a troupe of interesting characters arrives, claiming that the Cyclops really could predict the future, a wild goose chase begins for a seemingly innocuous set of blueprints.